Learn › How hieroglyphs work

Akhenaten and Moses: Freud, monotheism and the pharaoh people keep reinventing

16 November 2026

No ancient text links Akhenaten to Moses. The idea comes from the 20th century, above all from Sigmund Freud's last book, Moses and Monotheism, published in London in 1939. Freud argued that Moses was an Egyptian who had followed Akhenaten's one god and led a group of Semites out of Egypt after the king died.

What the evidence does show is a king who, around 1352 to 1336 BC, made the sun disc, the Aten, the only god of Egypt. His successors erased him, and he was almost unknown until his city at Amarna was dug up in the late 19th century. Since then historians, psychoanalysts, novelists and composers have kept making him into someone new.

Akhenaten made the Aten the only god

Early in his reign the king, still called Amenhotep IV, built temples to the Aten at Karnak. Around his fifth year he took the name Akhenaten and founded a new capital at Amarna. Later the names of Amun and other gods were hacked out of monuments, and the plural word "gods" was cut out in places too.

The Great Hymn to the Aten, carved in the tomb of the courtier Ay at Amarna, calls the Aten nṯr wꜥ (netjer wa), "sole god". The word nṯr, "god", is written with the cloth on a pole (), and wꜥ, "one, alone", with the harpoon ().

Scholars still argue over the word to use. Some call it monotheism, others henotheism, since only the king and queen could reach the god directly, and the people of Amarna went on keeping amulets of household gods.

Read the Aten's name sign by sign

Breasted called him the first individual in history

James Henry Breasted, the first American professor of Egyptology, called Akhenaten "the first individual in History". In his books, up to The Dawn of Conscience in 1933, the king became a lone thinker centuries ahead of his time.

Breasted also set the Great Hymn beside Psalm 104 of the Bible, which praises God for the same things: the night, the lions, the ships on the sea, the creatures of the earth. He thought the psalm was inspired by the hymn. In 1911 Arthur Weigall wrote that one could "hardly doubt that there is a direct connection". Later scholars doubt a direct link. Miriam Lichtheim put the likeness down to Egyptian hymns and biblical psalms sharing one way of praising a creator, though Jan Assmann and Donald Redford still see some Egyptian influence on the psalm.

Freud built his case on the name Moses

Freud published the first two parts of Moses and Monotheism in the journal Imago in 1937 and the whole book in 1939, months before he died in London. He started from the name. Breasted had written that Moses is "simply the Egyptian word 'mose' meaning 'child'".

The word is ms, "born", written with three fox skins () and the folded cloth () for its s. Freud pointed to royal names built on it: Thutmose, "born of Thoth", begins with the ibis on a standard () for the god, and Ahmose, "born of the moon", with the crescent moon ().

From there Freud built a story. Moses was an Egyptian of rank, a follower of the Aten, who after Akhenaten's death chose a Semitic people to keep his faith. They later killed him, he argued, and the guilt for that murder shaped their religion. Freud admitted the name alone "has not been considered decisive".

SignNameWhat it tells you
Thutmose G26 F31 S29ḏḥwty-ms, "born of Thoth"
Ahmose N12 F31 S29iꜥḥ-ms, "born of the moon"

See the cartouches of Thutmose III

Historians found no road from Amarna to Sinai

The dates do not meet easily. Redford pointed out that Moses, if he lived, probably lived a hundred years or more after Akhenaten. The first mention of Israel anywhere is on the stela of Merneptah, carved around 1208 BC, about 130 years after Akhenaten died, and most historians date the full worship of one god in Israel centuries later still.

No Egyptian record mentions Moses or the Exodus. The Egyptian origin of his name is itself disputed: Kenneth Kitchen and Thomas Schneider derive it from a Semitic verb, "to draw out". The archaeologist William F. Albright called Freud's book "totally devoid of serious historical method".

Assmann looked for a memory of Amarna

In Moses the Egyptian (1997) Jan Assmann asked where the forgotten king might have survived. He found a candidate in a story told by Manetho, an Egyptian priest of the third century BC, whose lost history is quoted by the Jewish writer Josephus.

In it, a priest of Heliopolis called Osarseph leads lepers and outcasts against a king named Amenophis, turns them against the gods and takes the name Moses. Assmann read the tale as a folk memory that mixed several bad times, Amarna and the rule of the foreign Hyksos among them, and later fastened them onto the Jews. He wrote about how Egypt and Moses were remembered and never claimed that the two men met.

Novelists and composers gave the king a voice

Thomas Mann's Joseph novels, finished in 1943, make Akhenaten the pharaoh who raises Joseph to rule Egypt beside him. Mika Waltari's The Egyptian (1945) tells his reign through Sinuhe, a doctor who in the end poisons him. Hollywood filmed it in 1954.

Naguib Mahfouz, the Egyptian Nobel prize winner, wrote Akhenaten, Dweller in Truth (1985). A young scribe, Meriamun, questions the people who knew the king after his death, among them Horemheb and Nefertiti, and each tells a different man.

Philip Glass's opera Akhnaten opened in Stuttgart on 24 March 1984. The king is sung by a countertenor, the words are in Egyptian, Akkadian and Hebrew, and only the Hymn to the Aten is sung in the audience's own language, followed by Psalm 104 in Hebrew from a hidden chorus. A recording of the Metropolitan Opera's staging, with Anthony Roth Costanzo, won a Grammy in 2022.

Fringe writers turned Akhenaten into Moses himself

Some writers go further than Freud. Ahmed Osman, in Moses and Akhenaten: The Secret History of Egypt at the Time of the Exodus, argues that the two were one man and that the king lived on in Sinai after he lost his throne. Immanuel Velikovsky's Oedipus and Akhnaton (1960) made him the model for the Greek Oedipus.

Osman and Velikovsky cite no Egyptian text for these claims. Akhenaten's names were cut out after his death, and Seti I left him off the king list at Abydos, so writers have had wide gaps in the record to fill. The Druze faith counts him among its prophets.

Akhenaten's names in his cartouches

Questions

Was Akhenaten the first monotheist?

He is the earliest ruler known to have made one god the only god of a whole country, from around his ninth year. Scholars argue whether to call it monotheism or henotheism, since the king stood between the Aten and everyone else.

What did Freud say about Akhenaten?

In Moses and Monotheism (1939) Freud argued that Moses was an Egyptian follower of Akhenaten's religion who passed it to the Israelites after the king's death. Historians reject the story. Freud's first draft of 1934 was subtitled "a historical novel".

Did Akhenaten write Psalm 104?

No one knows who wrote the psalm. Its picture of a creator who feeds every creature is close to the Great Hymn to the Aten, and some scholars think the Egyptian hymn influenced it. Others put the likeness down to the way hymns were written across the region.

Is the opera Akhnaten about the real pharaoh?

Yes. Philip Glass used texts of the time, among them the Great Hymn, letters from Amarna and lines from Egyptian inscriptions, and set them in their old languages. The story follows his reign from his father's funeral to the fall of his city.

Glossary

amulet
A small charm worn by the living or wrapped with a mummy for protection, often shaped like a sign such as the ankh or the scarab.
Egyptologist
A scholar who studies ancient Egypt: its language, writing, objects, buildings and history.
monotheism
Worship of one god only. Akhenaten made the sun disc, the Aten, the only god of Egypt for a few years, around 1340 BC.
pharaoh
The king of Egypt. The word comes from per-aa, "great house", a name for the palace that came to mean the king himself in the New Kingdom.
priest
A servant of a god in a temple, who washed, dressed and fed the god's statue each day. A high priest led the staff of a great temple.
scribe
A person trained to read and write, who kept accounts, wrote letters and copied texts. Few Egyptians could write, and scribes were well respected.
stela
An upright stone slab carved with words and pictures, set up in tombs and temples or to mark a border.
temple
The house of a god, where priests served the god's statue. Temples for dead kings kept up their offerings after death.
tomb
A burial place: a pit, a mastaba, a pyramid or rooms cut into rock. Its chapel was where the family brought offerings.

People in this article

Sources

More to read